MouseScrappers.com  

Go Back   MouseScrappers.com > Welcome > Help and Support
Click here to view our Sponsors Click here to visit us on Facebook Follow us on Pinterest
FAQ Community Calendar Today's Posts Search Virtual Pin Shop
Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 08-08-2010, 02:18 PM   #31
jujube
I'm on the tram
 
jujube's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Posts: 20
Points: 1,928
Quote:
Originally Posted by Natalie from Pa View Post
I do personally know someone that Disney has contacted and was told "NO MORE"! She was making free t-shirt designs and had a "Donate" link on her website. She is now not allowed to "publish" anything Disney related.

But on the other hand, Check out this store on ebay....
http://stores.ebay.com/Ginas-Treasure-Chest-Store

I know that she was contacted by Disney and now she uses "Licensed Disney Stickers" in her paper piecings instead of clip art. From everything that I have read however, she she seems to be still violating copyright/trademark laws. I know Disney knows she is selling these items and she has been for a number of years. Just some more food for thought!

I am guilty of having copyrighted & trademarked images in the freebies that I have offered. Not just on my blog but as a DISigner as well. I don't make much money on my blog and I made the freebies just because others liked them and wanted to use them. I have shared thousands of designs for t-shirts, journal pages, autograph page, planning cards, etc with no malicious intent. I made them for my own kids and thought someone else might enjoy using them as well. My husband and I made the decision to pull all copyrighted/trademarked images from my blog. I am going to close my photobucket as well. I can't afford a legal battle with Disney. It makes me so sad.......I feel as if I have been able to spread a little extra pixie dust by sharing this work and this will have to end for now.

The digi-designers here and DISigners on the DIS fill a need/market that Disney currently does not fill themselves. When we scrap photos of the beach....we use beach related elements, so why wouldn't want to scrap our beloved Disney photos with Disney elements! If there is ever an opening for a Disney digi-designer.... I really want to apply because that would be my DREAM JOB!
This was the person that I was going to post about. She is one of the only people that I've ever heard Disney went after. Someone contacted Disney and got her in trouble. It's really ridiculous. There are tons of ebay and etsy sellers who use Disney designs and some have been there for years. If Disney was serious about really wanting to shut down crafters and sellers, they would go to those sites.
This is from http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...dFabric.shtml:
Licensed fabric means the fabric is licensed by the rights owner to be manufactured and sold. It does not mean the fabric is licensed at the time it is sold. A license on the use of the fabric requires the person buying it to agree, usually in writing, to conditions on the use of the fabric before paying for the fabric. If you do not agree to the "license" before purchasing, they will sell the fabric to you anyway. In fact, no one even asks you if you agree to the license. They just sell you the fabric. Any fabric sold without a signed mutual agreement prior to the sale is not licensed and there are no provisions in the law that allow for otherwise. Any one who tells you otherwise is lying. And, under the definition of a "license", they would record your name and address, require periodic payments, and demand the fabric be returned to them when you are done with it. That just does not happen.

A copyright statement as defined in the US Copyright Act is using the symbol © along with the word "copyright" (or abbreviated "Copr."), the first year of publication of the work, and the name of the copyright owner. Nothing else. Any other statement by the copyright owner is irrelevant, extraneous, unenforceable and improper.


Maybe this is why Disney isn't more aggressive in going after people. The quote is about fabric but it seems like the the copyright issue would hold across the board. I'm not an attorney though so this is my own opinion.

I do understand you wanting to be careful Carol. Since I'm new here, I don't even know about the links/download forum but it is a shame that it had to close.
__________________
Julie

[

jujube is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 08-08-2010, 02:21 PM   #32
lauriesscraps
In Town Square, envisioning Walt giving his speech
 
lauriesscraps's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: USA
Software: CS4
Camera: Sony a300 DSLR
Posts: 118
Points: 3,742
Send a message via MSN to lauriesscraps
This is all I got from them:
Quote:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.
Then when I asked further to give me SOMETHING.... they just replied with this:
Quote:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.
So it seems they do not want to help at all.
Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar

lauriesscraps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 02:35 PM   #33
kateolas
Staying the night at Animal Kingdom Lodge
 
kateolas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Software: Photoshop CC 2017 and Photoshop CS2
Camera: GE X500, Sony CyberShot
Posts: 2,968
Points: 9,689
Quote:
Originally Posted by lauriesscraps View Post
This is all I got from them:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.

Then when I asked further to give me SOMETHING.... they just replied with this:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.

So it seems they do not want to help at all.

Sorry to laugh. But they don't seem concerned at all.

And here we are all freaking out.


Laurie have you looked into an IP tracker for your blog? At least you could compare the time comments are posted against the traffic at the same time on your blog. Then you would know where the comments came from. Or had a general idea where they came from.

Here is a link if you or any other blogger wants to track traffic.

http://www.bloggertipsandtricks.com/...mentators.html
__________________

Mouse Ears United States of America Mickey\'s glove Mickeys shoe Mickey\'s shorts I link to MouseScrappers! Minnie\'s Bow Minnie\'s Shoe Thanks for being an outstanding contributor Me!iss@! Teacups Pirate Flag Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar Earful Tower Sorcerer\'s Hat Pirate Ears Monorail Speed Scrapper! Expedition Everest Captain EO Cheshire Cat 1 Wish VoluntEAR - Castle Ive met another MouseScrapper

kateolas is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 03:12 PM   #34
lauriesscraps
In Town Square, envisioning Walt giving his speech
 
lauriesscraps's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: USA
Software: CS4
Camera: Sony a300 DSLR
Posts: 118
Points: 3,742
Send a message via MSN to lauriesscraps
Well, after looking at my blog a little more, I noticed it does have IP addresses included when I view the comments from the admin. It looks like this woman commented on my blog under 2 names, so one of them is the right one. At least now I know when I see her on forums, haha. I guess not so anonymous anyway.

I am just going to leave it. I changed my kits and it is all done now. It just would have been nice if they had emailed before doing what they did, including reporting me to Disney. Which Disney never contacted me about my stuff.

I just hope that all you scrappers out there will still be willing to buy our kits even if they do not have the Disney images or other Disney specific things in them. I know it might be harder to scrap with a kit that does not have these elements in them, but you would be surprised how good they can look with out these elements too. It makes you focus on the images and the kit compliments them. Just my 2 cents on it.

As far as the Disney emails go. I am not sure if they are not responding because they don't care, or if they just don't want to give me legal advice. Not sure.
Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar

Last edited by lauriesscraps; 08-08-2010 at 03:27 PM.

lauriesscraps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 05:07 PM   #35
WDW Scrap Princess
E Ticket Holder
 
WDW Scrap Princess's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: 1,103 Miles from MK
Software: CS6~PSE10~SBC
Camera: Nikon D3300
Posts: 7,119
Points: 27,465
I am just thinking what is the WORST that can happen if Disney contacts a Designer? They will say "Remove the images" they are removed then and thats it. I think the problem is if the Designer CONTINUES to use it AFTER being contacted. That is what I think. but please correct me if wrong....

I also think that by changing these not so nice people are controlling when apparently Disney does not care.
I would write a nice letter to Disney telling them about the scrapbooking and using a notary public, keeping a copy if Disney comes after the Designer, the Designer can always say they tried to contact the company but they never responded thus will avoid the coming after. Just what I think but again I could be wrong....
__________________
Disney Vacation Club Member Minnie\'s Bow Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) I link to MouseScrappers! Mouse Ears Mickey\'s glove Mickey\'s shorts It\'s a Small World Carousel horse Magical Express Sorcerer\'s Hat Boardwalk 1 Contemporary Resort 1 Rocket Jets Monorail Eiffel Tower Earful Tower Minnie\'s Shoe Mickeys shoe Pirate Flag I love DCL! Cheshire Cat 1 Beware of Hitchhiking Ghosts! Thanks for helping to make MouseScrappers a better place Teresa! Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar I got the Tree of Life for referring people to MouseScrappers! Cutester Minnie Dale Bambi

WDW Scrap Princess is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 05:20 PM   #36
AmyR0618
Arrived in Orlando, waiting for Magical Express
 
AmyR0618's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: MA
Software: ADobe Photoshop Elements
Camera: Canon EOS 40D, Canon Powershot
Posts: 885
Points: 7,124
I think all of this is VERY sad as I am sure many of you do also. Like it was mentioned in the thread, Disney doesn't have "Digi" kits...not even "traditional" scrapbooking kits until the last 5 years or so. I mean, there is definately a market for it. I am no lawyer, nor a designer, but I do enjoy the products produced by all our talented designers her on the forum. I understand the need to protect MS & yourselves. But, I would have to think if you were doing anything "illegal" then the first line of action Disney would take would be to issue a "cease and desist" order before taking anyone to court over it. So, that being said, I wouldn't get too scared off by one big mouth saying that they reported you. But, that is just my opinion.

Good luck with all of this and I do hope that we can get back to the innocence of scrapbooking
I link to MouseScrappers!

AmyR0618 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 05:22 PM   #37
AmyR0618
Arrived in Orlando, waiting for Magical Express
 
AmyR0618's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: MA
Software: ADobe Photoshop Elements
Camera: Canon EOS 40D, Canon Powershot
Posts: 885
Points: 7,124
Oh, and one more thing...if Mouse Scrappers had to be shut down for any reason, I think I may seriously need a rehab facility!!!
I link to MouseScrappers!

AmyR0618 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 05:24 PM   #38
WDW Scrap Princess
E Ticket Holder
 
WDW Scrap Princess's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: 1,103 Miles from MK
Software: CS6~PSE10~SBC
Camera: Nikon D3300
Posts: 7,119
Points: 27,465
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmyR0618 View Post
Oh, and one more thing...if Mouse Scrappers had to be shut down for any reason, I think I may seriously need a rehab facility!!!
I agree with you....I will be your partner at that facility.
__________________
Disney Vacation Club Member Minnie\'s Bow Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) I link to MouseScrappers! Mouse Ears Mickey\'s glove Mickey\'s shorts It\'s a Small World Carousel horse Magical Express Sorcerer\'s Hat Boardwalk 1 Contemporary Resort 1 Rocket Jets Monorail Eiffel Tower Earful Tower Minnie\'s Shoe Mickeys shoe Pirate Flag I love DCL! Cheshire Cat 1 Beware of Hitchhiking Ghosts! Thanks for helping to make MouseScrappers a better place Teresa! Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar I got the Tree of Life for referring people to MouseScrappers! Cutester Minnie Dale Bambi

WDW Scrap Princess is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 05:27 PM   #39
WDW Scrap Princess
E Ticket Holder
 
WDW Scrap Princess's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: 1,103 Miles from MK
Software: CS6~PSE10~SBC
Camera: Nikon D3300
Posts: 7,119
Points: 27,465
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmyR0618 View Post
I think all of this is VERY sad as I am sure many of you do also. Like it was mentioned in the thread, Disney doesn't have "Digi" kits...not even "traditional" scrapbooking kits until the last 5 years or so. I mean, there is definately a market for it. I am no lawyer, nor a designer, but I do enjoy the products produced by all our talented designers her on the forum. I understand the need to protect MS & yourselves. But, I would have to think if you were doing anything "illegal" then the first line of action Disney would take would be to issue a "cease and desist" order before taking anyone to court over it. So, that being said, I wouldn't get too scared off by one big mouth saying that they reported you. But, that is just my opinion.

Good luck with all of this and I do hope that we can get back to the innocence of scrapbooking
I agree with you here too. I would understand that MS would remove the links but If I would be a Designer I would not remove the images like you said they cannot take to court without a warning first and better yet if that Designer has a goverment proved document that shows that they TRIED to contact Disney FIRST to get permission but they DID not then Disney only has to blame Disney for not contacting the Designer. In the meantime we the consumer are deprived of our products and the bad persons in control. That is just what I think but I also understand how the Designer could get scared so I respect their decision.
__________________
Disney Vacation Club Member Minnie\'s Bow Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) I link to MouseScrappers! Mouse Ears Mickey\'s glove Mickey\'s shorts It\'s a Small World Carousel horse Magical Express Sorcerer\'s Hat Boardwalk 1 Contemporary Resort 1 Rocket Jets Monorail Eiffel Tower Earful Tower Minnie\'s Shoe Mickeys shoe Pirate Flag I love DCL! Cheshire Cat 1 Beware of Hitchhiking Ghosts! Thanks for helping to make MouseScrappers a better place Teresa! Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar I got the Tree of Life for referring people to MouseScrappers! Cutester Minnie Dale Bambi

WDW Scrap Princess is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-08-2010, 09:31 PM   #40
MJAJmom
E Ticket Holder
 
MJAJmom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Austin, Texas
Software: PSE 7.0
Posts: 4,543
Points: 13,728
freebie discussion

Great comments so far! Sometimes investigation into an issue is a good thing so that we can all seek the truth and do the right thing.

Both Disney and Star Wars have a HUGE fan base with lots of blogs, websites, clipart sites, info sites, etc. All of which display images that are copyright of the legal owner (disney or lucasfilms). The biggest issue is that they are not used for profit, but are used for personal, educational and entertainments purposes. For our freebies, the best places to search for guidance are clipart sites. These sites place disclaimers about copyright owners and personal usage. Two great examples are here:

http://i-love-disney.com/info/copyright.shtml
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Copyrights

I think for all of us creating freebies, that we should have some kind of disclaimer verbage directly on our blogsites as well as within our TOU that get downloaded with the freebie. I'm looking at various clipart sites, etc to check out all their verbage to figure out what I need to have, since I have freebies with disney images on them too.

I look forward to Carol's further investigation. I'm a huge supporter of DISboards and Mousescrappers, both of which have honest intentions, and both generate lots of interest in Disney which in the end yields more fans and thus more money for Disney. Disney is a huge marketing engine and they are most likely already well aware of this site and all of us little people. Nonetheless, it's always best to learn the guidelines and follow the guidelines, sometimes whether we like it or not.
__________________
Linda
Pirate Ears Minnie\'s Bow Sorcerer\'s Hat Mouse Ears Teacups Pirate Flag Monorail Carol helped me book my vacation! Magical Express Star Tours Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar Expedition Everest Rocket Jets United States of America Mickey Pumpkin

MJAJmom is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 09:18 AM.



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

© Copyright 2009 - 2024 MouseScrappers.com, All rights reserved.
MouseScrappers.com is not affiliated in any way with Walt Disney World, The Walt Disney Company, or any of their affiliates or subsidiaries.
Visit Disney's official web site at Disney.com As to Disney artwork, logos and properties: © Disney
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger