View Single Post
Old 06-30-2013, 05:33 AM   #9
*melidy*
E Ticket Holder
 
*melidy*'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: England
Software: Photoshop CC
Camera: Cannon
Posts: 3,115
Points: 6,921
I haven't completed a layout yet so my opinion may not mean anything, however, any challenge I have hosted there are a few layouts that don't follow the instructions to the letter but they receive the prize anyway, because this is a fun supportive environment and I personally don't see there being a 'wrong' way to interpret a challenge. A challenge should make you think and push the boundaries but ultimately the goal is to record a memory.
Whilst the colour match is not perfect, there are colours in there that are close. I feel the challenge has just been interpreted slightly differently.
I would be more concerned that requiring exact colours would put off new members, traditional scrapbookers and those who simply don't have many kits, may not be able to get an exact colour and may be intimidated by this. I am a frequenter of this site and even I feel a bit daunted by the challenge now...
Obviously this is your challenge and it is your decision ultimately, no matter what is said.
__________________
I link to MouseScrappers! Sleeping Beauty\'s Castle (Disneyland) I got Cinderella Castle for referring people to MouseScrappers! Sorcerer\'s Hat Earful Tower Mouse Ears Mickey\'s shorts Mickeys shoe Mickey\'s glove Minnie\'s Bow Minnie\'s Shoe Teacups Carousel horse It\'s a Small World Cheshire Cat 1 Jungle Cruise Pirate Flag Pirate Ears Thanks for hosting Mickey Bar Pirate Dog Mickey Pumpkin Beware of Hitchhiking Ghosts! Expedition Everest Captain EO Star Tours Monorail Minnie Bride United Kingdom France United States of America

*melidy* is offline