MouseScrappers.com

MouseScrappers.com (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/index.php)
-   Help and Support (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9636)
-   -   Links/downloads forum is locked for now - UPDATE! (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4987)

Carolc 08-04-2010 10:10 PM

Links/downloads forum is locked for now - UPDATE!
 
I have reluctantly locked the Links/Downloads forum until I have a chance to consult some legal counsel. I am worried that some of the items in these threads infringe on Disney trademarks/copyrights - not just the items for sale, but perhaps the freebies as well. My apologies for the sudden closure and I ask for your understanding and patience while I (hopefully) can get some information.

Thank you,
Carol

kaylalovesminnie 08-05-2010 09:25 AM

Wow Carol, I am sure everyone hear can agree we don't want you or the site to encounter any legal trouble. :no: I hope you can get some clear answers and I know you will make the best decision possible!!

Carolc 08-05-2010 09:31 AM

Thanks for your support, and I'm sorry for any inconvenience.

roxana 08-05-2010 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kaylalovesminnie (Post 34744)
Wow Carol, I am sure everyone hear can agree we don't want you or the site to encounter any legal trouble. :no: I hope you can get some clear answers and I know you will make the best decision possible!!

:agree:
I´m sure nobody wants MS having legal issues.:lovesite:

kateolas 08-05-2010 09:45 AM

Carol I have done more in dept research on this subject as of late since there are people out in the digi world that want to 'stir the turd' so it seems.

EVERYTHING is copyrighted.

Even those images for the avatars that are posted on this site.

Do you ever wonder why most of the books about the Disney parks has NO images in them ... that is because the images are also copyrighted. That means you can't put a picture of the castle on the cover of a book WITHOUT Disney's permission.

So all our digital pages ....... guess they are illegal too huh?


I'd love to have a face-to-face forum with the "haters" who started this battle as of late. We were all just fine and dandy ... not hurting anyone ... some just have to nag and complain because of their jealousy that some are making a small profit from digital creations ... not like they are making millions off their kits.

All this "finger pointing" is ridiculous !!!! Great people who take the time out of their busy lives with their families .... put these kits together and share them with the rest of us. Now they are being "punished" because of a few people who feel the need to ***** and moan about things.

They need to take up a new hobby ... and leave the Disney-scrappers alone !!!


My hats go off to all the digital designers that have offered Disney like offers here ...... and I stand behind them 100%.

When you drag "legalize" into a hobby ..... it sucks the fun right out of it. That is my opinion.

But Carol you being the owner of this board ... you have to do what you have to do. And we all understand that.


I look at it this way (and I have said it many times before) ... if I am going to be in JAIL .... by all means let it be Disney jail !!!!

ZIP-A-DEE-DOO-DAH !!!!! :whistle:

CarmenF 08-05-2010 09:46 AM

I am sure nobody will be upset! Being involved in the craft word this is something that has come up alot. I'm not sure of all the exact rules, but I think freebies are okay. Has anyone ever looked at the disney ribbon you can get at Walmart it actually says "Not to be used for anything other than personal use. Not to be resold" It is crazy. I can't remember how the Mousehead ribbon people get away with it but they can sell it. Maybe becasuse they design it there self and just call it mouse head not mickey mouse?? When I do my ribbon sculptures I always called them something else like Cindy for Cinderella or just Fairy for Tinkerbell and stuff. Someone had said that if we used some of our bows at Disney they would make us take them out which isn't true at all. Same for all the shirts I made us all...if that were true there would be a lot of naked people walking around Disney World. LOL Maybe one day we will figure out all this Disney Copyright stuff....it seems that this stuff gets realy scarey once every few months and it comes in waves. If I didn't love Disney so much I might get upset with them! LOL:lol2::lol2::lol2:

CarmenF 08-05-2010 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goofys_girl (Post 34749)
Carol I have done more in dept research on this subject as of late since there are people out in the digi world that want to 'stir the turd' so it seems.

EVERYTHING is copyrighted.

Even those images for the avatars that are posted on this site.

Do you ever wonder why most of the books about the Disney parks has NO images in them ... that is because the images are also copyrighted. That means you can't put a picture of the castle on the cover of a book WITHOUT Disney's permission.

So all our digital pages ....... guess they are illegal too huh?


I'd love to have a face-to-face forum with the "haters" who started this battle as of late. We were all just fine and dandy ... not hurting anyone ... some just have to nag and complain because of their jealousy that some are making a small profit from digital creations ... not like they are making millions off their kits.

All this "finger pointing" is ridiculous !!!! Great people who take the time out of their busy lives with their families .... put these kits together and share them with the rest of us. Now they are being "punished" because of a few people who feel the need to ***** and moan about things.

They need to take up a new hobby ... and leave the Disney-scrappers alone !!!


My hats go off to all the digital designers that have offered Disney like offers here ...... and I stand behind them 100%.

When you drag "legalize" into a hobby ..... it sucks the fun right out of it. That is my opinion.

But Carol you being the owner of this board ... you have to do what you have to do. And we all understand that.


I look at it this way (and I have said it many times before) ... if I am going to be in JAIL .... by all means let it be Disney jail !!!!

ZIP-A-DEE-DOO-DAH !!!!! :whistle:

Same thing in the crafting world. The funny thing is that you hear that something happened to someone, but you never hear it from the someone. I know that some people do get in trouble but typically it is the people that are selling things out right that they are taking from Disney. (pictures and stuff that is) The haters out there just need to get over it... Like I said it comes in waves and then it goes away. Honestly we aren't taking any business from Disney since they do not do anything like most of this stuff. I will keep making my Disney inspired stuff...make small changes and call them something else. hahaha Us true Disney lovers know what it is :) (Not just digital scrapping but also my craft stuff)

This Dixie Pixie 08-05-2010 12:07 PM

I hope that this isn't something that will be deemed necessary to stay permanent. :( Those links have been such a wonderful resource for me and I'm finally getting pages scrapped from our 2004. Unfortunately all our pages will be so blah without Disney papers and embellishments to enhance them. I do understand that you have to CYA though Carol. Of course you do and I support that decision. It's just a very sad day when the poo disturbers have to stir up trouble for people who are basically a very insignificant worry to the Disney corporation and their copyrights.

Melissa has pretty much hit it bang on the head - I am a moderator at a large Disney fan website and the owners of the boards happen to put out the best Disney Guide Books there are. ;) We have copyright discussions frequently with them and because they are authors and they write about Disney they are very careful about copyrights. However at the same time, every avatar and many signatures do technically violate copyright laws. This holds true with Disney, The Peanuts, Universal, Hello Kitty... if there's a message board, there are copyright violations on those message boards. Disney has never said anything to any Disney message board (not to my knowledge and I've been involved with Disney message boards since 2002) regarding people using Disney property in their avatars.

I truly hope this is a very short temporary measure!! :(

Mama-si 08-06-2010 11:31 AM

What I heard was that Lauriescraps was reported for Disney copyright violations and I know for sure she has taken down some of her Disney inspired work.

SO - knowing that it is out there.... trying to put a positive slant on it...

We can scrap all we want as long as we are not making money from it. We can use Disney pictures and things we create ourselves as long as we are not making money from it.

Even the freebies that are given out are technically in trade mark violation, particularly if they are a freebie that leads someone to a 'for sale' kit.

However, even though the forum links are gone from Mousescrappers, you can still look at the great layouts and when a credit is linked to a kit, you can easily find the kit and any freebies that may be offered. If a designer links her blog in her signature, you can use that to find kits and freebies to.

Disney is really protective of their trademarking. If they were not, then the courts wouldn't let them pick and choose who to go after. There are lots of ways to support disney scrappers and still stay withing the boundaries of trademarking. My educated guess is that Disney only goes after people who include trademarked images (such as the mouse ears and disney characters) and name (such as specific character names like the seven dwarves who were not in the original stories, park names or ride names).

I think, with a little engineering (removing an ear or two :) ) all the kits out there could support Disney scrappers (and designers) and keep Disney happy too!

Sand 08-06-2010 02:20 PM

Disney Co. got on the (traditional) scrapbooking train late, in my opinion, but at least now they have made supplies available in the parks as well as granting licenses to many scrap companies, like Creative Memories, Cricut and EK Success. Since digi scrap is not technically a physical product so a license would not be necessary (I think, I am not a lawyer) then what about copyright permission? Can't permission be granted to the Disney-inspired designers if they request it? Why couldn't they and Carol be granted a Terms Of Use from the Disney Interactive Media Group? (DIMG are the ones that oversee the official Disney internet sites.) Wouldn't this alleviating the threat of Disney lawyers threatining everything they own and thought of owning? Obviously, these can only be answered by Disney. So, I searched online for "Disney Copyrighted Permission" and found a DIMG address from a post on the cricut.com message boards (August 2009). This person wanted to sell journals with Disney characters on it at a school craft fair and got this response from Disney:

Thank you for contacting us.

To use our materials, please send your request in writing as follows:

The Walt Disney Company
ATTN: Margaret Adamic
Permissions
500 S. Buena Vista Street
Burbank, CA 91521-6305

Our permissions department can also be reached via telephone number
(818) 569-3128.

Thank you for your interest in Disney.

Best Regards,

Matt
Disney.com Guest Services


Anyone have any other suggestions?

Carol, I would LOVE LOVE for Mouse Scrappers to be THE OFFICIAL DISNEY DIGITAL SCRAPBOOKING SITE!! :yeah: There is a huge Disney digital market that, I hope, Disney Co. recognizes and would take MouseScrappers under their wing. :thumbsup:
Sandy

agrievingmommy 08-07-2010 09:19 AM

Carol - Check out this latest DST thread that I posted because a store deleted some of my layouts. It's crazy.... Can't we make a scrap page for ourselves and share it with others at all??? I really think this is all just a mess
"Denise - the problem isn't that you made it, and are using it for your own personal use. The problem starts when you "publish" your page - then, technically , you are using a known trademarked & copyrighted image without permission. Disney holds all rights to even that just plain black head and ears. A symbol such as that is called a 'service mark' - a well known symbol/logo that is identified with a particular brand or service...in this case, Disney. So - yeah...I can see why the store would have removed your page (which is very cute!). The reasoning for that is that the store would be in just as much trouble as you if they left it up. Disney has and will go after people for these kinds of violations.
I know it doesn't make sense that you could make that page, keep it on your computer or print it out and keep it in an album.....and you would be ok. But the minute you 'publish' it...which is exactly what its called when you upload it to a gallery - THEN you are claiming copyrighted Disney images as your own. The store that has the gallery you uploaded it to is liable also for hosting your image in its gallery. Thats why they took it out. "

Crazy... is all I can say and I'm so sorry Carol that you are having this extra added stress.

Carolc 08-07-2010 09:41 AM

Wow... if this is true, I might have to shut the whole site down? :cry: I know Disney is very protective of how their trademarks are used. I remember in college I went to an information night before interviews with Disney, and one of the students created a resume with Mickey Mouse on it. Not knowing any better, I thought it was pretty slick (i.e. why didn't I think of that?). But the recruiter got after him, saying something like 'Um, I don't want to see that...' and mentioned something about copyright or trademark. I can see how Disney would frown on that because it made it look as though Disney was somehow endorsing that guy. But scrapbook pages that sort of glorify how much we love our vacations at Disney parks? You'd think they would allow that. Think I should put any sort of disclaimer that these are personal pages that are not endorsed by Disney.

I am going to try to meet with an attorney this week, possibly on Wednesday.

agrievingmommy 08-07-2010 09:47 AM

ya, why can't we do a disclaimer??? or something... It's crazy. You'd think Disney would want us to be sharing our pages and fueling the Disney "craze" :) At the very least - I hope you can still keep the site open even if there are rules about what you can have in your lo. I love it here Carol!

agrievingmommy 08-07-2010 09:56 AM

If that's true, then how is DISBoards still open. There are pics of the parks, sillhouetted mickey ears, etc and just a disclaimer "This site is not affiliated in any way with the Walt Disney Company or any of its affiliates or subsidiaries. This site and the information contained therein represent the opinion of the webmaster. For official information on Walt Disney World, Click Here"

BevS97 08-07-2010 10:45 AM

I think there is a big difference between kits which are inspired by disney - using colours and items that to give the feeling of disney and remind you of the parks or characters, and kits which actually include disney character clipart or logos.

BevS97 08-07-2010 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by agrievingmommy (Post 35074)
If that's true, then how is DISBoards still open. There are pics of the parks, sillhouetted mickey ears, etc and just a disclaimer "This site is not affiliated in any way with the Walt Disney Company or any of its affiliates or subsidiaries. This site and the information contained therein represent the opinion of the webmaster. For official information on Walt Disney World, Click Here"

Photos will either be taken by the website's staff, in which case they are the property of the photographer, or they will be supplied by Disney. They have a photographic database that they offer to the media.

winipeg1 08-07-2010 01:25 PM

Oh my gosh, this seems to be really getting out of hand. hope you get some clarification on what you can and cant do carol. x

winipeg1 08-07-2010 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by agrievingmommy (Post 35074)
If that's true, then how is DISBoards still open. There are pics of the parks, sillhouetted mickey ears, etc and just a disclaimer "This site is not affiliated in any way with the Walt Disney Company or any of its affiliates or subsidiaries. This site and the information contained therein represent the opinion of the webmaster. For official information on Walt Disney World, Click Here"

this is a good point how do the DISigners get away with what they create?

BevS97 08-07-2010 01:39 PM

Just my personal opinion, and in no way backed up by anyone official, but I don't think Disney care about people who aren't making money.

It is in Disney's best interests for the forums to generate excitement in WDW, and people wearing t-shirts / decorated cruise doors and getting excited about their trips are all good for business.

Can you imagine the negative publicity if a family in matching Disney t-shirts where turned away at the gate? That's just not going to happen.


I, personally, think the problem really only arises if you use 'clipart' type Disney images and sell them. I am talking about images that were originally created by Disney.

eg this is not your image to sell.
http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/6...dyface2rz1.gif

however this one reminds you of Cinderella, but there isn't actually a copyrightable image in there, it just evokes a feeling of Cinderella.
http://shop.scrapmatters.com/images/...b38c1423eb.jpg

In my opinion, if you included the first image in a kit, then you may have a problem, but the 2nd one should be fine.

However, I am not a lawyer, and really have no knowledge of this situation officially, that's just my 'common sense' viewpoint.

WDW Scrap Princess 08-07-2010 01:41 PM

I am sorry to hear this Carol. The disclaimer sounds like a good idea. I would put that Rightaway up on the site right under Mousescrappers.com just in case, it does not hurt.

How does Creative Memories get a license with Disney?
Can MS get something similar?

I saw this one on DisneyClips.com and that is outright characters images!

* Please note that the clipart images on this website are intended strictly for non-profit purposes. The images displayed here are copyrighted by their respective owners. This website and all content contained on this website is not authorized by The Walt Disney Company.

All characters and images displayed on this page © Walt Disney Company, all rights reserved. The clipart images on this website are intended for non-profit purposes only. This website is not affiliated with the Disney Company.

Is is possible to put this even before you meet your attorney? Just in case?
just and idea.

leslie_537 08-07-2010 05:42 PM

I know on the DST thread someone posted that if it has your own drawn Mickey ears or a hidden mickey button set, Disney could come after you because it is published (to a gallery). If you need me to I can go through my scrapbook magazine's and show some pages where people created their own Disney stuff and CM published it.

Plus I was in a research group for Disney which I can't really discuss. But I had to send some things in and I put the pictures all on a scrapbook page. The person I spoke with at Disney for part of the survey loved them. She said it so creative, blah, blah, blah.... I told her that Disney should really come out with a Digital product line but digi designers do not make enough to pay for licensing.

Anyways my point it I had a lot of self created Disney stuff on those pages, and no one has come after me.

I highly doubt Disney can come after somone for making a personal family scrapbook page of their Disneyland trip. Seriously

The only time I see a problem are the kits that are sold with actual Disney ears, clipart etc... in them. Especially the clipart you did not create that and it is no different than taking a bow out of my kit and putting it in yours for sale. That is piracy! Now as for making a couple pieces of word art, hats, Mouse ears and sharing them on here. I really think that is a grey subject. If we give them away with our product packaging then in some way we are using them for personal gain, ie... more sales of other products. (it is one way they could look at it) But if we just give them away without product packaing we are sharing a personal item created with my own hands.

I really don't have the answers. But I would be completely flabergasted if Disney came after anyone for a personal scrapbook page they posted in the gallery here. They have bigger fish to fry, and I highly doubt they would want that negative publicity. I can see the headline's now:

Disney Sue's Stay At Home Mom for Scrapbooking her trip to Disneyland

Let us know what will come of all this Carol.

Natalie from Pa 08-07-2010 06:17 PM

I do personally know someone that Disney has contacted and was told "NO MORE"! She was making free t-shirt designs and had a "Donate" link on her website. She is now not allowed to "publish" anything Disney related.

But on the other hand, Check out this store on ebay....
http://stores.ebay.com/Ginas-Treasure-Chest-Store

I know that she was contacted by Disney and now she uses "Licensed Disney Stickers" in her paper piecings instead of clip art. From everything that I have read however, she she seems to be still violating copyright/trademark laws. I know Disney knows she is selling these items and she has been for a number of years. Just some more food for thought!

I am guilty of having copyrighted & trademarked images in the freebies that I have offered. Not just on my blog but as a DISigner as well. I don't make much money on my blog and I made the freebies just because others liked them and wanted to use them. I have shared thousands of designs for t-shirts, journal pages, autograph page, planning cards, etc with no malicious intent. I made them for my own kids and thought someone else might enjoy using them as well. My husband and I made the decision to pull all copyrighted/trademarked images from my blog. I am going to close my photobucket as well. I can't afford a legal battle with Disney. It makes me so sad.......I feel as if I have been able to spread a little extra pixie dust by sharing this work and this will have to end for now.

The digi-designers here and DISigners on the DIS fill a need/market that Disney currently does not fill themselves. When we scrap photos of the beach....we use beach related elements, so why wouldn't want to scrap our beloved Disney photos with Disney elements! If there is ever an opening for a Disney digi-designer.... I really want to apply because that would be my DREAM JOB!

Carolc 08-07-2010 07:32 PM

Thank you everyone for the information you've shared as well as your ideas. I just want everyone to know that I decided to lock the two product threads at least until I can get more information. I know there is a person proudly reporting designers to Disney, and I am worried that it is only a matter of time before that person finds our site here. And we are basically sitting on a large cache of info in those two threads. While I think many of the designs are perfectly fine, I know that some of them are definitely trademark infringement and should not be sold. The freebies? Well, I'd like some clarity on that but don't know if anyone but Disney can answer that. So I want to protect both our members, who also are also designers, and the site until we can get some clarification (well, if we can). Natalie, I know you have been so giving all these years, and I hate to see you pull things off your blog so abruptly. From what I've seen of your work, you are not selling trademarked names/images like 'Gina' - I really don't know how she is getting away with that. I didn't intend for any of you to take drastic measures. I just need to first know if I am putting myself in lawsuit danger for knowingly allowing/encouraging the product threads.... because if they shut me down it will affect all of you.

I have tentatively set up a consultation with an attorney that was recommended to me. It is going to start off at $200 for the first hour and go from there. I may at some point ask for donations to help with these costs if anyone is able to help.

Thanks everyone for your support and patience. Let's stick together on this.

WDW Scrap Princess 08-07-2010 07:38 PM

Sending Pixies your way!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Carolc (Post 35123)
Thank you everyone for the information you've shared as well as your ideas. I just want everyone to know that I decided to lock the two product threads at least until I can get more information. I know there is a person proudly reporting designers to Disney, and I am worried that it is only a matter of time before that person finds our site here. And we are basically sitting on a large cache of info in those two threads. While I think many of the designs are perfectly fine, I know that some of them are definitely trademark infringement and should not be sold. The freebies? Well, I'd like some clarity on that but don't know if anyone but Disney can answer that. So I want to protect both our members, who also are also designers, and the site until we can get some clarification (well, if we can). Natalie, I know you have been so giving all these years, and I hate to see you pull things off your blog so abruptly. From what I've seen of your work, you are not selling trademarked names/images like 'Gina' - I really don't know how she is getting away with that. I didn't intend for any of you to take drastic measures. I just need to first know if I am putting myself in lawsuit danger for knowingly allowing/encouraging the product threads.... because if they shut me down it will affect all of you.

I have tentatively set up a consultation with an attorney that was recommended to me. It is going to start off at $200 for the first hour and go from there. I may at some point ask for donations to help with these costs if anyone is able to help.

Thanks everyone for your support and patience. Let's stick together on this.


Count on my Support Carol. I think it is a good idea to be cautious.
please keep us informed as how it goes and again I am sorry for all this events...We do not have a Pixies Icon but Pixies going your way!

Teresa

PrincessTiff 08-07-2010 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carolc (Post 35070)
I can see how Disney would frown on that because it made it look as though Disney was somehow endorsing that guy. But scrapbook pages that sort of glorify how much we love our vacations at Disney parks? You'd think they would allow that.

I just can't imagine Disney going after someone for making a scrapbook layout from a vacation at one of THEIR parks. Imagine the negative publicity they would get from that. I could see them going after someone trying to sell clipart, however. What a mess.:no:

PrincessTiff 08-07-2010 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Natalie from Pa (Post 35117)
The digi-designers here and DISigners on the DIS fill a need/market that Disney currently does not fill themselves. When we scrap photos of the beach....we use beach related elements, so why wouldn't want to scrap our beloved Disney photos with Disney elements! If there is ever an opening for a Disney digi-designer.... I really want to apply because that would be my DREAM JOB!

Is there any way you and the other designers could actually make that happen? It might be a long shot but yall are amazing and it couldn't hurt to look into it.:blush:

Step 08-08-2010 06:55 AM

Directly from Lauries site:
http://www.lauriesscraps.com/blog/?p=2182

Quote:

I was contacted recently by someone who left a not so nice comment on my blog for all to see with out coming to me first, and who felt it necessary to come to my place of business to do so. This person said I was infringing on Disney copyrights. This came as a shock to me because I try very hard to be honest in all I do and had asked several other people, designers and scrappers who all said they thought what I had designed was ok. No images were taken from Disney to design these kits and everything in the kits were designed by myself from scratch.

So in order to stay away from even any appearance of copyright infringement, I have pulled my original “Fairest One of All”, “Toy Chest” and “Magic Moments” kits to rework them and re-release them. So if you want these kits, please be patient and give me a little time to rework them. I hope you can all understand that any infringement that one may think I have done was not intentional. I tried very hard to change things and not make them the same but still give you a kit that you would like to create with. I value my integrity very much.

Thank you for the understanding and thank you in advance for not leaving unnecessary “not so nice” and pointless comments.
Sounds like someone made a snarky comment on her blog, not that she was reported for anything. In response she did the sensible thing and reworked her kits to remove the "disney"-ness. I think a lot of the kits we all use could easily be reworked that way.

I've seen comments like these before (and I hope Britt doesn't mind me digging through her site to find this again, lol )

http://brittishdesigns.blogspot.com/...iss-kitty.html

Quote:

Anonymous said...
how exactly do you get around the Disney copyright issues? creating things even for free with their logos, icons, or characters is a really big copyright violation...very illegal.

SEPTEMBER 8, 2009 2:39 PM
Brittney said...
I never EVER make money or promote my business with anything copyrighted. I just make items for my own personal use and share them for free with friends if they want 'em. :)

SEPTEMBER 8, 2009 2:41 PM
I'd say you should bring copies of some kit and freebie previews that are here on the site and see what the lawyer's opinion is on what kind of stuff is legal and what isn't.

I'm sure that theming a kit in "toy story" colors, with some round circles that you COULD if you wanted to, form into mickey ears might be ok. (but I'd check about whether people show casing their scrapbook pages with the mickey ears reattached would then be a violation)

I hate to say it, but once you get a clear outline of what is ok and what isn't, you may wanna wipe out what's on here and start policing the kits. I think we can all do this without getting into any legal trouble. :)

kateolas 08-08-2010 07:14 AM

Quote:

Check out this latest DST thread that I posted because a store deleted some of my layouts. It's crazy.... Can't we make a scrap page for ourselves and share it with others at all??? I really think this is all just a mess
It's all getting WAY too out of hand. One person (or a small group of people) get a bug up their *** and throw all of us into panic mode. It's ridiculous !!!!!

Quote:

If that's true, then how is DISBoards still open. There are pics of the parks, sillhouetted mickey ears, etc and just a disclaimer "This site is not affiliated in any way with the Walt Disney Company or any of its affiliates or subsidiaries. This site and the information contained therein represent the opinion of the webmaster. For official information on Walt Disney World, Click Here"
They can write whatever they want ... they are still in some form violating copyright. If Disney would come after them, it wouldn't take too long to NOT be protected from their little disclaimer.

Quote:

Photos will either be taken by the website's staff, in which case they are the property of the photographer, or they will be supplied by Disney. They have a photographic database that they offer to the media.
This is untrue ..... even the images WE take in the parks .... the castle, rides, characters ... those are all Disney property. We really have no right to use them. To print our pictures and look at them ourselves yes, but to publish them on a gallery or even the cover of a book NO ... you have to have permission to use those images for anything put into print.

Quote:

I am guilty of having copyrighted & trademarked images in the freebies that I have offered. Not just on my blog but as a DISigner as well. I don't make much money on my blog and I made the freebies just because others liked them and wanted to use them. I have shared thousands of designs for t-shirts, journal pages, autograph page, planning cards, etc with no malicious intent. I made them for my own kids and thought someone else might enjoy using them as well.
Natalie ... this is what really makes me mad .... out of the kindness of your heart ---- YOU take the time out of your busy life to share this stuff with the rest of us (just like the rest of the wonderful digi designers here) ...... and now everyone is running scared with their stuff taking it down and there are still these people on eBay (that Disney knows about); and are still selling like crazy.

DISNEY ... will probably never hop on the digi bandwagon. Like Leslie said .... the licensing would cost more than the design itself.

And if Disney ever had that negative headline come up ANYWHERE sueing someone for scrapbooking ... I think a lot of hoopla would come over it. They are out to make money ..... not get negative press. And they make the money .... it isn't like their business is hurting any !!!!

I'd take 10% of what they pull in daily from one park!!!


If there was a way to get MS as the "official" Disney scrapping site .......... oh boy would this be a fun place. But we'd still have the problem with the designers selling the kits that would be the problem. That is where the big problem is lying. That permission I don't think would trickle over to the designers here .... they would have to have their own permissions as well.

I really don't think is the "copyright" issue with some of these complainers. I think it is the fact that they didn't hop on the Disney designing bandwagon first, and see now how some of these digi designers are making money. It I am sure ... isn't a lot ....... but people get snippy when they see other people successful .... and have to throw a wrench in it.

I am pretty sure that is what happened here. And if any of them EVER want to turn in one or any of the digi designers .... said accused will know EXACTLY who to go after ... all copyright complaints are public knowledge and you have to give your name and all pertinent info if you file a complaint.

Quote:

If there is ever an opening for a Disney digi-designer.... I really want to apply because that would be my DREAM JOB!
Wonder if there is a way to make that happen? I'd be the happiest girl on earth if they would even give me a graphic design job .....

Quote:

I know there is a person proudly reporting designers to Disney, and I am worried that it is only a matter of time before that person finds our site here.
Gee .... where would one find said person and link? :lol2:

Quote:

Anonymous said...
how exactly do you get around the Disney copyright issues? creating things even for free with their logos, icons, or characters is a really big copyright violation...very illegal.
I like how it's Anonymous. Come on ... put your real name and a link for goodness sakes !!!! :lol2: Should ask Anon if they want some cheese with their whine. BIG CHEESE ... gee or is that a copyright infringement too? :lol:

I'm sorry .... I have to laugh ......these complainers are just ridiculous !!!

lauriesscraps 08-08-2010 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mama-si (Post 34985)
What I heard was that Lauriescraps was reported for Disney copyright violations and I know for sure she has taken down some of her Disney inspired work.

Yes, I was left a comment on my blog letting me know that I had been reported by someone other than the person leaving the comment. They were very sarcastic and condescending. They were also in a sense anonymous because all that was left on my blog when they commented was the email address, which gets me nothing. I also didn't want to start a war with them, so I left it. I had no idea I was infringing. I saw so many other designers doing it that I thought I was ok. I found out I was not.
It would have been nice if they mentioned something in a private email, not on my blog, and with out reporting me with no hesitation. I thought that was very thoughtful.....UGH! But I took them down and reworked them and have re released them with out the infringed items. So I hope you can all have fun still with what I still have and what I have added to the kits. Still trying to figure out the infringement stuff.

I contacted Disney myself about it and they did not want to give me any direction on it but instead told me to go research it myself. So who knows. sad that Disney can't give people direction on that. You think they would want to help. Guess not.

pennylayne 08-08-2010 12:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lauriesscraps (Post 35172)
Yes, I was left a comment on my blog letting me know that I had been reported by someone other than the person leaving the comment. They were very sarcastic and condescending. They were also in a sense anonymous because all that was left on my blog when they commented was the email address, which gets me nothing. I also didn't want to start a war with them, so I left it. I had no idea I was infringing. I saw so many other designers doing it that I thought I was ok. I found out I was not.
It would have been nice if they mentioned something in a private email, not on my blog, and with out reporting me with no hesitation. I thought that was very thoughtful.....UGH! But I took them down and reworked them and have re released them with out the infringed items. So I hope you can all have fun still with what I still have and what I have added to the kits. Still trying to figure out the infringement stuff.

I contacted Disney myself about it and they did not want to give me any direction on it but instead told me to go research it myself. So who knows. sad that Disney can't give people direction on that. You think they would want to help. Guess not.

(pardon all the questions)

Really?! Disney couldn't give you any direction at all? what department was it? Did they refer you to Disney legal department? I'd like to help in some way. I have a few legal peeps up my sleeve and would be happy to contact, or find a way to contact ABC/DISNEY legal myself.

I would be hesitant to ask Disney to create a digi designer job. I would hate to see a dis-esq kit to soar in prices just becuase it's suddenly "officially licensed" . With Disney getting the lions share and the DISigner getting sqat.

jujube 08-08-2010 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Natalie from Pa (Post 35117)
I do personally know someone that Disney has contacted and was told "NO MORE"! She was making free t-shirt designs and had a "Donate" link on her website. She is now not allowed to "publish" anything Disney related.

But on the other hand, Check out this store on ebay....
http://stores.ebay.com/Ginas-Treasure-Chest-Store

I know that she was contacted by Disney and now she uses "Licensed Disney Stickers" in her paper piecings instead of clip art. From everything that I have read however, she she seems to be still violating copyright/trademark laws. I know Disney knows she is selling these items and she has been for a number of years. Just some more food for thought!

I am guilty of having copyrighted & trademarked images in the freebies that I have offered. Not just on my blog but as a DISigner as well. I don't make much money on my blog and I made the freebies just because others liked them and wanted to use them. I have shared thousands of designs for t-shirts, journal pages, autograph page, planning cards, etc with no malicious intent. I made them for my own kids and thought someone else might enjoy using them as well. My husband and I made the decision to pull all copyrighted/trademarked images from my blog. I am going to close my photobucket as well. I can't afford a legal battle with Disney. It makes me so sad.......I feel as if I have been able to spread a little extra pixie dust by sharing this work and this will have to end for now.

The digi-designers here and DISigners on the DIS fill a need/market that Disney currently does not fill themselves. When we scrap photos of the beach....we use beach related elements, so why wouldn't want to scrap our beloved Disney photos with Disney elements! If there is ever an opening for a Disney digi-designer.... I really want to apply because that would be my DREAM JOB!

This was the person that I was going to post about. She is one of the only people that I've ever heard Disney went after. Someone contacted Disney and got her in trouble. It's really ridiculous. There are tons of ebay and etsy sellers who use Disney designs and some have been there for years. If Disney was serious about really wanting to shut down crafters and sellers, they would go to those sites.
This is from http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...dFabric.shtml:
Licensed fabric means the fabric is licensed by the rights owner to be manufactured and sold. It does not mean the fabric is licensed at the time it is sold. A license on the use of the fabric requires the person buying it to agree, usually in writing, to conditions on the use of the fabric before paying for the fabric. If you do not agree to the "license" before purchasing, they will sell the fabric to you anyway. In fact, no one even asks you if you agree to the license. They just sell you the fabric. Any fabric sold without a signed mutual agreement prior to the sale is not licensed and there are no provisions in the law that allow for otherwise. Any one who tells you otherwise is lying. And, under the definition of a "license", they would record your name and address, require periodic payments, and demand the fabric be returned to them when you are done with it. That just does not happen.

A copyright statement as defined in the US Copyright Act is using the symbol © along with the word "copyright" (or abbreviated "Copr."), the first year of publication of the work, and the name of the copyright owner. Nothing else. Any other statement by the copyright owner is irrelevant, extraneous, unenforceable and improper.


Maybe this is why Disney isn't more aggressive in going after people. The quote is about fabric but it seems like the the copyright issue would hold across the board. I'm not an attorney though so this is my own opinion.

I do understand you wanting to be careful Carol. Since I'm new here, I don't even know about the links/download forum but it is a shame that it had to close.

lauriesscraps 08-08-2010 02:21 PM

This is all I got from them:
Quote:

Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.
Then when I asked further to give me SOMETHING.... they just replied with this:
Quote:

Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.
So it seems they do not want to help at all.

kateolas 08-08-2010 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lauriesscraps (Post 35183)
This is all I got from them:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.

Then when I asked further to give me SOMETHING.... they just replied with this:
Dear Guest,
Thank you for your letter.
Unfortunately, The Walt Disney Company is unable to provide legal advice to guests. We do appreciate your consideration in researching the issue at hand.

So it seems they do not want to help at all.


:lol2::lol2::lol2: Sorry to laugh. But they don't seem concerned at all.

And here we are all freaking out.


Laurie have you looked into an IP tracker for your blog? At least you could compare the time comments are posted against the traffic at the same time on your blog. Then you would know where the comments came from. Or had a general idea where they came from.

Here is a link if you or any other blogger wants to track traffic.

http://www.bloggertipsandtricks.com/...mentators.html

lauriesscraps 08-08-2010 03:12 PM

Well, after looking at my blog a little more, I noticed it does have IP addresses included when I view the comments from the admin. It looks like this woman commented on my blog under 2 names, so one of them is the right one. At least now I know when I see her on forums, haha. I guess not so anonymous anyway.

I am just going to leave it. I changed my kits and it is all done now. It just would have been nice if they had emailed before doing what they did, including reporting me to Disney. Which Disney never contacted me about my stuff.

I just hope that all you scrappers out there will still be willing to buy our kits even if they do not have the Disney images or other Disney specific things in them. I know it might be harder to scrap with a kit that does not have these elements in them, but you would be surprised how good they can look with out these elements too. It makes you focus on the images and the kit compliments them. Just my 2 cents on it.

As far as the Disney emails go. I am not sure if they are not responding because they don't care, or if they just don't want to give me legal advice. Not sure.

WDW Scrap Princess 08-08-2010 05:07 PM

I am just thinking what is the WORST that can happen if Disney contacts a Designer? They will say "Remove the images" they are removed then and thats it. I think the problem is if the Designer CONTINUES to use it AFTER being contacted. That is what I think. but please correct me if wrong....

I also think that by changing these not so nice people are controlling when apparently Disney does not care.
I would write a nice letter to Disney telling them about the scrapbooking and using a notary public, keeping a copy if Disney comes after the Designer, the Designer can always say they tried to contact the company but they never responded thus will avoid the coming after. Just what I think but again I could be wrong....

AmyR0618 08-08-2010 05:20 PM

I think all of this is VERY sad as I am sure many of you do also. Like it was mentioned in the thread, Disney doesn't have "Digi" kits...not even "traditional" scrapbooking kits until the last 5 years or so. I mean, there is definately a market for it. I am no lawyer, nor a designer, but I do enjoy the products produced by all our talented designers her on the forum. I understand the need to protect MS & yourselves. But, I would have to think if you were doing anything "illegal" then the first line of action Disney would take would be to issue a "cease and desist" order before taking anyone to court over it. So, that being said, I wouldn't get too scared off by one big mouth saying that they reported you. But, that is just my opinion.

Good luck with all of this and I do hope that we can get back to the innocence of scrapbooking :no:

AmyR0618 08-08-2010 05:22 PM

Oh, and one more thing...if Mouse Scrappers had to be shut down for any reason, I think I may seriously need a rehab facility!!!

WDW Scrap Princess 08-08-2010 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AmyR0618 (Post 35196)
Oh, and one more thing...if Mouse Scrappers had to be shut down for any reason, I think I may seriously need a rehab facility!!!

I agree with you....I will be your partner at that facility.

WDW Scrap Princess 08-08-2010 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AmyR0618 (Post 35195)
I think all of this is VERY sad as I am sure many of you do also. Like it was mentioned in the thread, Disney doesn't have "Digi" kits...not even "traditional" scrapbooking kits until the last 5 years or so. I mean, there is definately a market for it. I am no lawyer, nor a designer, but I do enjoy the products produced by all our talented designers her on the forum. I understand the need to protect MS & yourselves. But, I would have to think if you were doing anything "illegal" then the first line of action Disney would take would be to issue a "cease and desist" order before taking anyone to court over it. So, that being said, I wouldn't get too scared off by one big mouth saying that they reported you. But, that is just my opinion.

Good luck with all of this and I do hope that we can get back to the innocence of scrapbooking :no:

I agree with you here too. I would understand that MS would remove the links but If I would be a Designer I would not remove the images like you said they cannot take to court without a warning first and better yet if that Designer has a goverment proved document that shows that they TRIED to contact Disney FIRST to get permission but they DID not then Disney only has to blame Disney for not contacting the Designer. In the meantime we the consumer are deprived of our products and the bad persons in control. That is just what I think but I also understand how the Designer could get scared so I respect their decision.

MJAJmom 08-08-2010 09:31 PM

freebie discussion
 
Great comments so far! Sometimes investigation into an issue is a good thing so that we can all seek the truth and do the right thing.

Both Disney and Star Wars have a HUGE fan base with lots of blogs, websites, clipart sites, info sites, etc. All of which display images that are copyright of the legal owner (disney or lucasfilms). The biggest issue is that they are not used for profit, but are used for personal, educational and entertainments purposes. For our freebies, the best places to search for guidance are clipart sites. These sites place disclaimers about copyright owners and personal usage. Two great examples are here:

http://i-love-disney.com/info/copyright.shtml
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:Copyrights

I think for all of us creating freebies, that we should have some kind of disclaimer verbage directly on our blogsites as well as within our TOU that get downloaded with the freebie. I'm looking at various clipart sites, etc to check out all their verbage to figure out what I need to have, since I have freebies with disney images on them too.

I look forward to Carol's further investigation. I'm a huge supporter of DISboards and Mousescrappers, both of which have honest intentions, and both generate lots of interest in Disney which in the end yields more fans and thus more money for Disney. Disney is a huge marketing engine and they are most likely already well aware of this site and all of us little people. Nonetheless, it's always best to learn the guidelines and follow the guidelines, sometimes whether we like it or not.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:33 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© Copyright 2009 - 2024 MouseScrappers.com, All rights reserved.
MouseScrappers.com is not affiliated in any way with Walt Disney World, The Walt Disney Company, or any of their affiliates or subsidiaries.
Visit Disney's official web site at Disney.com As to Disney artwork, logos and properties: © Disney
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger