MouseScrappers.com

MouseScrappers.com (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/index.php)
-   Help and Support (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9636)
-   -   Links/downloads forum is locked for now - UPDATE! (http://mousescrappers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4987)

snowdrop 08-09-2010 12:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WDW Scrap Princess (Post 35193)
I am just thinking what is the WORST that can happen if Disney contacts a Designer? They will say "Remove the images" they are removed then and thats it. I think the problem is if the Designer CONTINUES to use it AFTER being contacted. That is what I think. but please correct me if wrong....

This is what I'm thinking. One time (non scrap related) a site I helped run got an email from someone demanding we removed images, and we did right away, and there was no problem. Funny enough, the only reason the person found us is because we fully believed in credit & copyright, and credited every image or we didn't use it. We thought we were doing the right thing, and that's how they found us lol. This was only a couple of pictures from thousands, and we were never contacted from any other photographer, but we decided to just shut the site completely down.

I would definitely agree about having some kind of note on the bottom of the forum about not being related to the Walt Disney company, etc (it was worded better earlier in the thread. ;))

I'm not a lawyer, but I don't see anything wrong in freebies or in linking to the products in the threads. But I completely understand wanting to look into it more. From Laurie's email, it doesn't seem like Disney cares. If they did, this has been going on for years (from the DISigners to digi scrapping), and they could have contacted someone by now telling them to stop. As others have said, I've seen a ton of stuff for sale on ebay and esty, and that seems much worse, but it's still allowed.

And I would think they'd say "stop this" before they took any kind of legal action. I REALLY don't see them caring about anyone's layouts, and I think the gallery that removed someone's Disney layout is really ridiculous. I wouldn't even want to visit that site.

Mama-si 08-09-2010 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lauriesscraps (Post 35172)
Yes, I was left a comment on my blog letting me know that I had been reported by someone other than the person leaving the comment. They were very sarcastic and condescending. They were also in a sense anonymous because all that was left on my blog when they commented was the email address, which gets me nothing. I also didn't want to start a war with them, so I left it. I had no idea I was infringing. I saw so many other designers doing it that I thought I was ok. I found out I was not.
It would have been nice if they mentioned something in a private email, not on my blog, and with out reporting me with no hesitation. I thought that was very thoughtful.....UGH! But I took them down and reworked them and have re released them with out the infringed items. So I hope you can all have fun still with what I still have and what I have added to the kits. Still trying to figure out the infringement stuff.

I contacted Disney myself about it and they did not want to give me any direction on it but instead told me to go research it myself. So who knows. sad that Disney can't give people direction on that. You think they would want to help. Guess not.

Laurie - I read some of the remarks the person you mentioned made about you on other sites, and that she had reported you to Disney. If it is any consolation, you received a great deal of support from everyone who was part of the discussion. I also commend you for your proactive approach on reworking your kits. If Disney ever did contact you, they are big on 'good faith' behaviour! I read about a party site that was using Disney costumes as part of their party offerings and they did not send the costumes to Disney, but returned them to Peru where they had been purchased. Disney took this as a sign of bad faith and sued them. Your kits are beautiful and will be just as useable in their new format, I'm sure.

I know Creative Memories is a licensed Digi resource for Disney images. I'm not sure what the cost is, but I believe it is quite high.

There are some great designers who show their stuff on this site - I'm sure that all of you are creative enough to make the kits work without using Disney trademarked images or sayings.

Carol, I'm sure there are plenty of people here who would shoot you a donation if you need it to help cover attorney fees. You are doing this all out of your own pocket and we appreciate it so much.

This is an awesome site... I can't wait to meet some of you IRL tomorrow :)

WDW Scrap Princess 08-09-2010 11:52 AM

I have a question:

Can the Designers sell the Kit and offer the Disney Images as Freebies?
sort of Free with purchase of the kit (if the kit does not have any trade graphics of course?

MJAJmom 08-09-2010 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WDW Scrap Princess (Post 35284)
I have a question:

Can the Designers sell the Kit and offer the Disney Images as Freebies?
sort of Free with purchase of the kit (if the kit does not have any trade graphics of course?

Nope. Free has to be totally free with no strings attached, where everyone is eligible to obtain it. If you must first purchase a kit in order to get the second 'free with purchase' item, then that still considered a selling for-profit event. Because the only way to get it is by making a purchase.

RuthieRoo 08-09-2010 02:31 PM

Wow, this all seems so crazy. I have no legal knowledge but who would of thought that scrapping our Disney vacation memories would be so controversial. I do hope that your legal advice pays off Carol and that we can continue making fun & fantastic layouts on here. It would be so sad if we had to stop!!! :no:

Mama-si 08-09-2010 04:59 PM

I don't think the layouts will ever be a problem - scrapping people having loads of fun is a good thing for Disney. Disney will also let people know if there is a problem, so it should just be business as usual. The only thing in doubt are the items with Disney Trademarked items and the freebies with Disney Trademarked items. If anything else is an issue, I'm sure we will hear about it if it is important enough.

We should all relax and have fun and know we will hear if there are issues...

cmtscrap 08-10-2010 01:08 PM

Hope everything went well with the lawyer Carol. It's a sad day when we may not be able to share our photos and good times at Disney with other Disney lovers.

You have my support no matter what happens.

tiggernjen 08-10-2010 07:26 PM

I didn't see this thread when I post mine about missin' freebies...I don't understand why people do some of the things they do??? What is wrong about using disney related items on your LO's??:confused: Cricut sells all the disney cartridges, Sandylion & EK has a whole line of Disney products, so I don't understand why we can't use them when doing a Disney LO..:no: Am I missing something here??? I have several paper albums filled with my Annual Pass, maps of all the parks, etc. is that consider a no-no too...

:lovesite: It has helped this newbie with learning how to digi scrapbook & helping me with PSE...:)

pennylayne 08-10-2010 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tiggernjen (Post 35432)
I didn't see this thread when I post mine about missin' freebies...I don't understand why people do some of the things they do??? What is wrong about using disney related items on your LO's??:confused: Cricut sells all the disney cartridges, Sandylion & EK has a whole line of Disney products, so I don't understand why we can't use them when doing a Disney LO..:no: Am I missing something here??? I have several paper albums filled with my Annual Pass, maps of all the parks, etc. is that consider a no-no too...

:lovesite: It has helped this newbie with learning how to digi scrapbook & helping me with PSE...:)

RE the highlighted: These companies hold official use licenses from the Walt Disney Company. They pay a fee in return for the use of official Disney images. Annual passes and maps are private property and absolutely you can use them in your albums. You just can't scan them and sell the images to make money.

AnnAbbott 08-11-2010 10:10 AM

I am sorry to see the links closed. I am new to Disney scrapping working on only my 2nd book. It helped me discover designers who love Disney. :(

jujube 08-11-2010 10:15 AM

Maybe this is a dumb idea but why not have the Disney licensed images as freebies. Sell the kits and have the freebies available but not as free with purchase. If someone ( like me :) ) is looking for digital kits the biggest reason is it's a pain to search for or to design all of the individual elements that make up the design, paper, embellishments,etc. The easiest is finding all of the Disney pieces-just google but if they're available as a freebie on a site with kits, then I'm buying from that resource because then I don't have to spend time trying to find it. Just a thought

NikkiFB 08-11-2010 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jujube (Post 35489)
Maybe this is a dumb idea but why not have the Disney licensed images as freebies.

I've been following this thread with interest... as an old journalism student and sometime-writer I'm really interested in copyright stuff. (I know, it's sick, lol.)

I think even freebies may be considered copyright infringement. B/c it's not JUST about making $$, it is also about quality control. (I assume that's why sometimes you see the disclaimer notices---saying that the Disney company didn't have anything to do with this and therefore isn't responsible for quality or problems, etc.) And I can understand that concern on the part of any company, including a giant like Disney.

Now I'm a person who LOVES the freebies!!! :D Sorry if I'm sounding like a party-pooper, cuz I would HATE to see the Disney goodies disappear. :( :(:( My guess is there is a BIG difference between what Disney COULD LEGALLY do, and what they WOULD ACTUALLY BOTHER to do. But copyright laws are there to protect everybody---no matter how big the "big guy" is, or how small the "little guy" is. (Think of all the "no piracy please" notices on all the digi freebies we download!)

Mama-si 08-11-2010 05:23 PM

Hey, everyone... cheer up! Our designers have TONS of products available that work for Disney layouts. You can scrap your pictures and post them all you want unless we hear otherwise... You can share the pictures that you took (as long as you don't sell them!). The only items that are affected are those that have Disney trademarked images or phrases!

Look at the layouts you love, click on the credits and check out the products. Many of the designers still have freebies on their sites that you can get and kits that work wonderfully for your Disney layouts.

It's not all gloom and doom :) We have this amazing site - just a few of the kits that are available are affected by this. I would be willing to guess that a lot of the designers haven't pulled the affected kits, so you can probably still buy them and/or get the freebies if you go to their blogs. They might choose to wait until/if Disney contacts them. I'm sure that Carol just chose to close the threads in case it put her in a difficult position.

Brighten up :) Cheer up :) Scrap some Disney layouts. You don't need Mickey Mouse ears or a Princess sticker for people to recognize your favourite place on earth!! :)

Look at this fabulous challenge Weekly Challenge - "Tell Your Story"!

Or the template challenge HERE

There are also Speedscrap, Telephone and Photo Swap Challenges

Don't let this little blip get you down! Let it get you... :scrapbooking: SCRAPBOOKING!

Mama-si 08-11-2010 05:38 PM

If anyone is interested in reading a little bit more about Trademark Infringment (copyright is more about authorship of works such as books, music, poetry, etc.)

http://www.bitlaw.com/trademark/infringe.html
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/metasch.../domain/tm.htm

Of course - you really could be scrapping, which would be MUCH more interesting...

Aussiegirl 08-18-2010 02:18 PM

Carol, do you have any more information on this? Did you meet with your lawyer? What was the outcome? Just wondering!

WDW Scrap Princess 08-18-2010 02:28 PM

I am wondering about the same thing! What was the result of it?

Carolc 08-18-2010 09:27 PM

Hi everyone,

I had a meeting scheduled with a lawyer last week, but I received a nice message from one of our own members asking if I could delay the meeting as she might be able to help. Her husband is a lawyer and several of his good friends specialize in trademark/copyright cases. All of them sat down together and took a good look at the site, addressing all the questions I prepared. The member then called me a few nights ago to go over all the thoughts and ideas that came up. At this time, I'm comfortable with the advice that was given and don't feel like it is necessary to meet with the (original) lawyer at this time (though I told him I may contact him again in the future if I start to lose my sense of comfort). I am going to implement some of their suggestions, and I think we MAY be able to open up the product threads again IF people promise to abide by the rules - which will need to be modified a little. Please give me a chance get some written up before I open them up again - I want to get some input from the moderators.

Though I'd like to publicly thank the member who took the time to do this for our community, I will let her remain anonymous (unless she wants to come forward). I just don't want her to get bombarded with questions or requests for advice. I know the legal fees could have added up very quickly for me, so I'm very, very appreciative of the lawyers' generosity.

Thank you everyone for your patience and support - I'll let you know what the plan is for the two threads.

tiggernjen 08-18-2010 09:42 PM

Hi Carol,
That is great news...:) I know you have been working very hard on this issue and I am glad that one of our fellow members husband was able to help you..I got a lot of freebies from that site and sure everyone will be happy when it is open again...:yeah:

Mama-si 08-18-2010 09:52 PM

To the wonderful anonymous member - thank you from all of us!!

PrincessTiff 08-18-2010 11:42 PM

That was so sweet of the anonymous member's husband to help you out, Carol.:sorcerer:

buttner-jenkins 08-19-2010 01:33 AM

OH MY, what a touching gesture. It's such a nice feeling to know that there are some genuine people out there that care and were able to help out.

Who ever you are, you and hubby & support team are just SOO AWESOME. A simple thanks from any of us here on the forum just couldn't do it justice, but little me will give it a go here. :thanks: for keeping this forum going for us all here.

gillscott 08-19-2010 04:34 AM

Nice to see that this is being sorted:thanks: so much to whoever helped

luv2scrapmm 08-19-2010 06:02 AM

So glad to hear that things are working out!

And let me add my :thanks: to our anonymous friend and her hubby (and his partners) for all their work! Please pass it along that we are very grateful!

WDW Scrap Princess 08-19-2010 06:12 AM

Please convey our heartfelt THANKS!
to both the Member of the community that offer and the kind soul that is helping us! THis is Wonderful!

cmtscrap 08-19-2010 10:47 AM

To the anonymous member and her husband...Thank you, thank you, thank you!!

roxana 08-19-2010 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmtscrap (Post 36340)
To the anonymous member and her husband...Thank you, thank you, thank you!!

:agree: with Charlene!
A million thank you´s :flowers:

scrappinnewbie 08-19-2010 01:29 PM

Many Thanks
 
I too would like to add my thanks. :thanks: I am glad your DH was able to help our site. I know it must be a huge burden lifted for Carol. Thank you for taking the time to review the law and policies. I am happy the issue has been solved without a huge cost.

Thanks again.

Melinda

Carolc 08-19-2010 01:36 PM

I just want to clarify, it was not just her DH, but also his associate and two collaborating attorneys - so four attorneys plus our member deserve our gratitude. :)

otter005 08-19-2010 01:44 PM

:yeah::yeah::yeah::hooray::hooray::hooray::thanks: :thanks::thanks:

liriel 08-19-2010 02:05 PM

Carol this is wonderful. One less stress for you then! Many thanks to the wonderful member, her DH and all of his associates!!!!:hooray:

tiggernjen 08-19-2010 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carolc (Post 36370)
I just want to clarify, it was not just her DH, but also his associate and two collaborating attorneys - so four attorneys plus our member deserve our gratitude. :)

A hugh thank you goes out to our member, DH, his associates and the other two collaborting attorneys....:yeah: For all their help!!!!

WDW Scrap Princess 08-19-2010 02:24 PM

after the whole thing is over we should do a "collaboration Page"
with a big Mickey saying THanks" oh wait maybe not a Mickey welll something like that!:D

Neverland Scraps 08-19-2010 03:26 PM

I've been for away for a month, so all this is very new to me . . . but I am glad to hear that this fabulous team have worked and given you answers that you were looking. I cannot wait to hear/see the new rules being implemented in to keeping this fabulous site!:yeah:

ana_carol 08-19-2010 05:16 PM

Im glad everything was solved
HUge thanks to all that helped you Carol

jujube 08-19-2010 09:08 PM

Thanks so much to anonymous, her husband, his partners, and Carol thank-you too for this wonderful place to see and learn.

winipeg1 08-20-2010 01:48 AM

thanks to all involved in helping Carol. This site is the best!!!

Aussiegirl 08-20-2010 09:37 AM

wow, tha'ts great news Carol! I'm so glad you were able to get some help and advice regarding this matter!

I will patiently wait to see what the new rules and guidelines are! thanks for letting us know what is going on in the mean time!:flowers:

Carolc 10-21-2010 07:24 PM

We have reopened a new and improved "Products" (for sale) forum. Leslie has worked really hard on this for the benefit of our community - now you'll be able to find products easier! Note that since the freebies are still very controversial, we will address it at a later date.

Please see the following threads:

Rules: http://www.mousescrappers.com/forums...ead.php?t=5466

'site map': http://www.mousescrappers.com/forums...ead.php?t=5515

Hope you like the new format!


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© Copyright 2009 - 2024 MouseScrappers.com, All rights reserved.
MouseScrappers.com is not affiliated in any way with Walt Disney World, The Walt Disney Company, or any of their affiliates or subsidiaries.
Visit Disney's official web site at Disney.com As to Disney artwork, logos and properties: © Disney
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger